Lecture 1 (1) - Merged
Lecture 1 (1) - Merged
Treatment
• The only practical means to overcome these limitations is to conduct a detailed inventory
and measurement studies at each potential source in a community.
• As a first step in developing a community inventory, potential sources of hazardous
waste are to be identified.
https://cpcb.nic.in/inventory/
CPCB 2022-2023
Percentage of HW generation
Percentage of HW generation
➢ In order to have a proper control over hazardous waste management, the regulatory
authorities should specify the occupier or generator of hazardous waste:
• To keep a complete record of the types, quantities, and characteristics of hazardous waste.
• To segregate hazardous waste at source from non-hazardous waste.
• To transport hazardous waste only through the specified and registered transporters.
• To dispose of hazardous waste only at the notified disposable facilities.
• The regulatory authorities shall ask the occupier or generator to submit quarterly reports.
• The authorities should ensure that the occupier/generator sends a copy of the manifest to
them as soon as the hazardous wastes is shipped for ultimate disposal.
• The regulatory authorities may allow the occupier/generator to store his hazardous waste
on-site provided that:
o The waste is stored in the specified containers and occupier/generator follows the
requirements for storing in the containers.
o The date upon which each period of storage begins is clearly marked and visible on each
container.
o While being stored on-site, each container is labelled or marked with the words
"HAZARDOUS WASTE" , both in English and respective local language.
• The regulatory authorities may allow the occupier/generator to store his hazardous waste
on-site a maximum quantity of 10,000 kg or a truckload whichever is less for a maximum
period of 90 days.
• If an occupier/generator generates less than 1,000 kg of hazardous waste in a month, he
may be considered as a small quantity generator. Such type of generators may be allowed to
store their waste on-site for a maximum period of 180 days. In any case, the quantity of
waste should not exceed 6,000 kg at any given point of time.
• The regulatory authorities may provide an extension in the storage period to the occupier, on
case-by-case basis, provided that:
o An occupier/generator who generates less than 1000 kg of hazardous waste in a month and
who transports his waste more than a distance of 500 km for off-site storage, treatment
and/or disposal may be allowed to store hazardous waste on-site for a maximum period of 270
days at the discretion of regulatory authorities.
o In any case, the quantity of waste should not exceed 10,000 kgs at any given point of time.
• At all times, there must be at least one employee either on the premises or on call with the
responsibilities for co-ordinating all emergency response measures.
• To inspect the on-site storage areas for proper storage.
• In order to track the hazardous waste from the source of generation to the final disposal
points, the regulatory authorities should introduce the manifest system. This system should not
only help the regulatory authorities in tracking the hazardous waste but also ensure the safe
disposal of the waste. The manifest system would serve as a "chain of custody" document.
Every time the shipment changes hands, the responsible persons sign the manifest.
COLLECTION
• The waste generator, or a specialized hauler, generally collects the hazardous waste
for delivery to a treatment or disposal site.
• The stored containers are transported unopened to the treatment and disposal facility.
Flatbed truck
Railroad tank car
• India has close to 8,000 towns and cities as per Census 2011, has never officially estimated the domestic
hazardous waste it generates. Traces of this toxic waste, though, can be found in most landfills.
• In 2020, researchers from the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Delhi and IIT Bombay analyzed eight
dump sites across the country — including Delhi, Mumbai, Kadapa (Andhra Pradesh), Hyderabad and
Ahmedabad.
• They found a significant level of toxic heavy metals and persistent organic contaminants like pesticides at
these sites. There is a very real possibility that a large portion of this toxicity is due to dumping of domestic
hazardous waste. But in the absence of proper monitoring, there is no way of ascertaining just how much.
• According to the rules, households must segregate waste into wet, dry and domestic hazardous
categories. Local government bodies must collect the hazardous waste, and/or set up collection centres
every 20 km so households can deposit it on their own. The local authorities must then safely deliver the
collected waste to disposal facilities. The rules also direct the authorities to develop the necessary
infrastructure and sensitise people by 2018. But none of these requirements have translated on the
ground.
• Even if the waste is collected, the country does not
have enough disposal facilities to safely treat them.
A disposal facility typically has engineered landfills
that stop the percolation of toxic leachate into the
ground, and/or incinerators.
• Currently, there are only 45 of these facilities, as
per the Handbook on Chemicals and Hazardous
Waste Management and Handling in India released
in 2019 by the Union Ministry of Environment,
Forest and Climate Change.
• At least 18 states and Union Territories, including
Delhi, Bihar and Assam, do not have safe disposal
facilities. Twelve others such as Punjab and
Haryana, have one facility for the entire state.
• There a total of 5250 SATs, out of which 4500 are operating under GHMC and 750 are
operated by private agencies. Official sources admit that only 3600 of them are collecting
garbage daily.
Case Study - 3
There is a fine of Rs 200 per violation for residential areas and Rs 10,000 per violation for commercial areas. Those not segregating four types of
waste - dry, wet, sanitary and domestic hazardous - will be issued challans through water bills. Throwing horticulture waste in the open will attract
a fine ranging from Rs 200 to Rs 500.
TRANSPORTATION
MoEF guidelines for transportation of hazardous waste:
• Transportation of hazardous waste being the important link in hazardous waste management
system, it requires precise control to ensure safe disposal of such wastes.
• The transporters of hazardous waste have to be registered with the Department of
Environment & Forests in addition to the Department of Transport. This would enable the
Ministry of Environment and Forests/respective State Pollution Control Boards to ensure safe
and secured transport of hazardous wastes.
• To ensure that the occupier/generator transport their hazardous waste only in the specified
transport vehicles.
• The transporters should be asked to train the drivers and helpers of hazardous waste transport
vehicles to handle the wastes under emergency situations.
FACILITIES FOR HAZARDOUS WASTE
• Facility is a land, structure, and other appurtenances used for storing, recovering,
recycling, treating, or disposing of hazardous waste.
• Many generators construct and operate their own captive facilities referred to as on-
site facilities.
• Other generators, not having a suitable site or not generating a sufficiently large
volume of waste to justify the investment in an on-site facility, transport their waste
to specialized facilities for treatment and disposal. Such facilities are referred to as
commercial, off-site facilities.
Major categories of facilities for Hazardous Waste
Recover material as a sellable product (typically solvents,
1 oils, acids, or metals); some recover energy values in waste
Permanent emplacement
of waste on or below
3 land surface
Recovery Facilities
➢ SOLVENT RECOVERY
o These facilities separate contaminants from waste solvents and thus restore the solvent to
its original quality or to a lower grade product.
o Distillation is used by most commercial solvent processors, and typically recovers about
75% of the waste solvent.
o The residue can be a liquid or a sludge, and requires management as a hazardous waste.
o Other separation technologies used by solvent processors include filtration, simple
evaporation, centrifugation, and stripping.
1. The spent solvent is fed,
either automatically or
manually depending on the
equipment, into the
distillation vessel.
2. The distillation vessel is
fitted with a thermal oil
jacket that is heated by one
or more electric heaters
which brings the spent
solvent to its boiling point.
3. Once the waste is separated, the recovered solvent vapors are channeled to an air cooled
condenser, where it cools into its liquid form.
4. The liquid is then directed to the clean solvent collection drums, where it can be reused.
➢ OIL RECOVERY
• Used lubricating oils can be recovered to a quality essentially equal to virgin lubricating
oils. This process is typically referred to as oil re-refining.
• Two methods may be employed in waste oil re-refining:
a) Acid/clay method
b) Distillation method (capital-intensive)
• Because the former produces a large amount of spent acidic clay residue, distillation is
preferred.
(a) Acid/Clay Method
Pre-treatment
Base Oil
Acidic sludge
• In the acid clay process, used oil is typically filtered and then heated to remove debris,
solid particles and water.
• It is then mixed with sulfuric acid which extracts metal salts, acids, aromatics, and other
impurities. This forms a by-product of acidic sludge that settles out of the oil.
• The remaining slightly acidic oil is mixed with active fuller’s earth (clay) to remove other
contaminants and to improve color.
• After clay is filtered from the oil, the final steps are neutralization and distillation of the
oil.
(b) Distillation Method
➢ Pre-treatment
• Used oil is heated and treated with chemicals to
separate suspended solids and water content in
preparation for the Distillation process.
➢ Distillation
• To remove heavy metals, contaminants and ash
content from used oil, to recover re-refined oils
and other petroleum fractions.
➢ Solvent Extraction
• After distillation, the re-refined lubricant is
further processed with a solvent that extracts the
final stages of impurities and aromatic
compounds from the oil, resulting in clean, high
quality specification Base Oil products
• Distillation cuts are the output streams from a distillation tower. They are called "cuts"
because they are the result of separating the crude oil into its constituent parts based
on the different temperatures at which they evaporate and condense.
• The typical distillation cuts coming from atmospheric distillation and vacuum
distillation are:
a) Refinery gas - made up of methane and ethane. This stream remains a gas and is sent
to the fuel system
b) Propane - Blended into LPG or used as refinery fuel
c) Butane - blended into LPG or used as refinery fuel
d) Kerosene - Used to make jet fuel or blended into diesel
• Vacuum Tower Bottoms are the left over bottom products of distillation, which can be
used for upgrading into gasoline and diesel. They are the heaviest material in the
refinery tower. If allowed to cool to room temperature, Vacuum Tower Bottoms would
become a solid.
➢ METALS RECOVERY
• The technologies for recovering metals can be grouped as pyrometallurgical or
hydrometallurgical.
• Pyrometallurgy uses the differences in melting and boiling properties to separate metals
at high temperatures.
• The hydrometallurgy technology extracts and concentrates metals from liquid waste
using any of a variety of processes such as ion exchange, reverse osmosis, membrane
filtration, adsorption, solvent stripping, and precipitation. Non-liquid wastes first require
dissolution.
➢ Fuel blending for hazardous waste reduction is a
process where hazardous waste materials (such as
industrial solvents, used oils, and contaminated
fuels) are mixed with conventional fuels to create a
usable energy source.
1. Waste Solvents
Sources: Paint manufacturing, pharmaceuticals, chemical plants
Examples: Toluene, xylene, acetone, Methyl ethyl ketone (MEK), Alcohols (ethanol, methanol)
Benefit: High-energy content, easily combustible
⚠ Heavy Metal-Containing Wastes – Lead, mercury, cadmium (can cause toxic emissions)
⚠ Highly Halogenated Waste – PVC, fluorinated compounds (produces toxic dioxins/furans)
⚠ Explosive & Reactive Wastes – Peroxides, highly unstable chemicals
⚠ PCBs & Dioxin-Contaminated Oils – Highly regulated due to extreme toxicity
➢ CO-INCINERATION IN INDUSTRIAL KILNS/FURNACES
• The manufacturers of cement, light aggregate, and some other products use a special
type of rotary kiln.
• The destruction of hazardous waste by co-incineration with primary fuels and raw
materials in such industrial kilns has been practiced for a long time.
• Cement kilns operate at high temperatures (2600-3000F) and provide very long
residence times, which make possible very high destruction of Principal Organic
Hazardous Constituents (POHCs).
• The waste may be blended at the site where the waste is burned or blended at a separate
facility and shipped to the site of the industrial kiln.
Treatment Facilities
Incinerator
❑ Objectives of Stabilization
✓ Immobilize Contaminants – Prevent leaching of heavy metals, organics, and toxic chemicals
✓ Reduce Toxicity – Convert hazardous compounds into less harmful forms
✓ Improve Structural Integrity – Solidify waste to enhance handling and disposal
✓ Meet Regulatory Standards – Ensure compliance with environmental laws
❑ Applications of Stabilization
✓ Industrial Wastewater Treatment – Stabilization of heavy metals
✓ Radioactive Waste Management – Vitrification of nuclear waste for permanent disposal
✓ Hazardous Soil Remediation – Stabilization of oil spills, pesticides, and PCB-contaminated soils
✓ Landfill Waste Treatment – Cement-based stabilization before hazardous waste landfill disposal
Land Disposal Facilities
➢ LANDFILL
• A landfill involves permanent emplacement
of hazardous waste.
• In many instances, waste will undergo some
form of pretreatment (eg. Stabilization) prior
to land disposal. Emplacement would occur
either in relatively shallow trenches or in
vaults.
• A landfill facility has several protective
elements (eg. Liners), to contain emplaced
wastes, to minimize the generation of
leachate, and to remove leachate as it is
generated.
➢ DEEP WELL INJECTION
• This disposal method features injection of liquid
waste into a deep, porous subsurface geological
formation.
• The receiving formation is well below potable
aquifers and should have an impermeable
confining layer above it.
• The injection well consists of the injection pipe
surrounded by a series of concentric casings,
containing cement and noncorrosive fluids to
prevent leakage into shallow formations.
Waste Management flow diagram for fully integrated hazardous waste
management facility
Incinerator slag is the solid byproduct left after waste is burned in an incinerator. It contains a mix of non-
combustible materials, metals, glass, and mineral residues.
FACILITY OPERATIONS
• The operations at a hazardous waste facility consist of five subsystems:
• A waste analysis plan is a critical part of a facility. The plan specifies the parameters
for which each waste will be analyzed, the sampling and analytical methods to be
used, and the frequency of analysis.
• Before a facility treats, stores, or disposes of a waste, it must profile the waste,
including a detailed chemical and physical analysis of a representative sample of the
waste. Commercial facilities require this full characterization prior to shipment by the
generator.
a) Determine if the waste is acceptable for receipt at the facility in terms of the
capability of the facility to treat or dispose of the waste.
b) Identify the inherent hazards of the waste so that appropriate precautions can be
taken during its handling and storage at the facility to prevent incidents.
3
WASTE RECEIVING
• Waste shipments typically arrive by truck at a facility’s gatehouse.
• Upon accepting the waste, the facility signs the manifest and sends a copy to the generator. At
that point, the facility shares liability with the generator and transporter.
• It is critical that the pre-shipment waste analysis has already been completed and the shipment
scheduled.
• Without prior scheduling of the incoming shipment or if the shipment is improperly
documented, the gatehouse will refuse entry of the truck.
• Scheduled and properly documented shipments are directed to the receiving station where any
packaging is checked, the loaded truck is weighed, and representative samples are collected for
testing the parameters.
• The waste may arrive as bulk liquids in a tank truck, containerized liquids or sludges in drums,
bulk shipments of contaminated soil in dump trucks, or by a number of other methods.
• Collecting a representative sample can pose a difficult task considering that the waste may
be in multiple phases and states or have pockets of high contamination.
• The receiving station must use previously established procedures for each situation to ensure
the collection of a representative sample.
• Upon collection of the sample, the laboratory analyses various parameters of the waste.
• Upon verification of the waste shipment, the truck is directed to an unloading area where it
is emptied and then reweighed before it leaves the facility.
• The mere “emptying” of a truck can pose a difficult challenge if the waste has stratified, a
container has leaked, or a solidification reaction has occurred.
• It is important that facilities have planned procedures and are prepared with special
equipment to resolve such problems.
• The truck may need to be decontaminated to remove any trace residues.
WASTE STORAGE AND PREPARATION
• Upon unloading, the wastes are moved into storage that can consist of tanks or
impoundments for bulk liquids, hoppers for solids and sludges, or pads and warehouses
for containers.
• A key issue in providing safe storage is compatibility. This has two independent
considerations:
1. The compatibility of the waste with the material used to construct the container, tank, or
liner in contact with the waste (eg. Certain solvents should not be stored in plastic
containers)
2. The compatibility of the waste with other wastes stored together (eg. Containers of
cyanide waste should not be located near acid waste)
• The key is to segregate incompatible wastes by placing them in separate areas constructed
of suitable materials. If stored together, incidents such as leaks could result in mixing of
incompatible wastes. Different chemical reactions could occur. Some reactions could
produce excessive pressure, thus posing fire or explosion hazards. Others could produce
toxic fumes or gases.
• Certain types of wastes will require prior mixing. For example, the concentration of waste
constituents can vary considerably because of large differences in incoming waste strength.
This is particularly true at most commercial treatment facilities. Mixing can control such
variations to arrange that will not upset performance of the subsequent unit treatment
processes.
• Some waste must undergo other forms of preparation before feeding to the waste
treatment processes. For example, contaminated soil can obtain rocks, bricks, and
reinforcing rods that could damage materials handling equipment if not removed.
WASTE TREATMENT
• While the waste is maintained in storage, a treatment schedule is developed that will
identify the waste to be treated, any necessary preparations, the method of treatment,
and the rate at which the waste is fed.
• Upon commencement of waste treatment operations, the waste is typically fed by bulk
materials handling systems such as pipelines or conveyors to the equipment used to
perform the prescribed treatment steps.
• The selected method of treatment not only depends upon the type of waste but on the
waste’s individual physical and chemical characteristics and the specifications for the
treated waste.
General suitability of various treatment methods versus
characteristics of waste
RESIDUALS MANAGEMENT
• An incinerator, for eg., produces combustion gases that require scrubbing that in turn
produces an acidic washwater requiring wastewater treatment. Incinerator also
produces fly ash requiring disposal, if not treatment.
• The unit treatment processes are not the only operations that generate residuals.
Spillage and runoff from storage areas require treatment.
• A full-service facility can usually provide all necessary treatment of residuals. Smaller
facilities may have to collect the residuals and transport them as hazardous waste to
another facility capable of treating them.
Integrated hazardous waste treatment processes
SPECIAL MEASURES
• A hazardous waste facility needs to take a number of special precautionary measures for all
of its day-to-day operations, these measures can be quite complex for full-service,
commercial facilities and much less involved for single purpose, on-site facilities.
Nevertheless, both types of facilities need all of these measures to prevent incidents.
• In fact, the permitting process requires that the permit application provide detailed plans
and procedures on how the facility will implement precautionary measures. These
measures can be listed as follows:
❑ Security ❑ Employee training
❑ Inspection and maintenance ❑ Safety
❑ Incident prevention ❑ Monitoring
❑ Emergency planning ❑ Audits
➢ A facility needs to provide SECURITY to prevent
vandals and intruders who could
o become exposed from contact with waste,
o damage the equipment, or
o cause illicit dumping
• Most facilities use a combination of
o security guards,
o total enclosure with fences,
o adequate lighting,
o proper warning signs, and
o 24-hour surveillance
➢ A facility needs regular and thorough INSPECTION of its equipment, structures, and other
appurtenances with preventive and corrective MAINTENANCE taken.
• This requires preparing a list of
o items to be inspected,
o a schedule, and
o the typical problems that may be encountered
• The inspection should examine
o process equipment,
o storage areas,
o emergency equipment,
o monitoring equipment, and
o security devices
• Basically, the inspection should check for equipment malfunctions, structural deteriorations,
operator errors, and discharges that could lead to the release of hazardous waste constituents.
• Some critical components of a facility require daily inspection. For eg. The operator should inspect
storage areas, looking not only for leaks but for signs of corrosion and mismanagement (say loose
lid on a drum). The unloading area is critical to inspect because of the higher potential for spills.
➢ It is important to implement INCIDENT PREVENTION measures to minimize the possibility
of a fire, explosion, spill or any other unplanned, sudden release of hazardous waste
constituents.
• Such a program begin by conducting a risk analysis to identify hazards and potential
incidents.
• The risk analysis would indicate the routine activities and waste processing operations
that have a higher probability of initiating an incident.
• In this way, preventive measures can be instituted and appropriate responses planned in
the event one of the more probable incidents were to occur.
• For eg. Fire is a major concern. Having alarms, fire control equipment, water if adequate
pressure, and personnel trained to fight fires is important, but so is maintaining adequate
aisle space to allow unobstructed movement of fire protection equipment.
➢ If an incident occurs, the facility should follow a set of procedures prepared in part of an
EMERGENCY PLAN that describes the actions that facility personnel should take in
response to fires, explosions, or other incidents.
• The plan should provide for interaction with local police departments, fire
departments, hospitals, and other appropriate emergency and community services.
• The plan should also describe evacuation procedures for facility personnel.
• Practice drills are important.
• One facility employee should be appointed as emergency coordinator and take
leadership responsibility for implementing the plan.
➢ It is important that the facility train its
employees to perform their duties
effectively and safely and to know how to
respond to an emergency.
• The TRAINING usually consists of both
classroom instruction and supervised on-
the-job training.
• Each employment position should have a
description of its responsibilities and duties,
the content of the necessary introductory
and continuing training.
➢ One of the most important measures is ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING – collecting
samples of the environmental media and testing for the presence of hazardous
substances that may have been released by the facility.
• The objective is to detect potential problems before they impact human health and the
environment.
• Early detection should allow sufficient time for adequate warning of potentially
impacted individuals and effective implementation of remedial measures.
• Important monitoring points are ground water wells for storage and land disposal
facilities and air monitoring stations at critical locations around the facility.
• Monitoring could also include surface water, employees (blood samples), and flora and
fauna.
➢ REGULATORY COMPLIANCE is essentially the driving force for the entire facility. The
operation of a facility is thus geared around managing waste in a manner that meets the
environmental regulations.
➢ AUDITS are an excellent tool for ensuring that the facility operating staff is complying with
all standard operating procedures, best management practices, and regulatory
requirements.
• Diverse groups from outside the facility conduct periodic inspections and audits from
varied perspectives.
• The regulatory authorities inspect the facility to determine compliance with regulatory
requirements.
CLOSURE PLAN FOR THE HWM FACILITY
➢ The closure of a hazardous waste management facility can occur for several reasons, including
regulatory, environmental, financial, and operational factors.
1. Regulatory Non-Compliance
• Violation of environmental laws and regulations (e.g., improper waste disposal, emissions, or
leakage)
• Failure to renew permits
• Non-compliance with safety standards, leading to government-imposed shutdowns
• Legal actions due to community complaints or lawsuits
2. Environmental and Public Health Risks
• Groundwater or soil contamination beyond permissible levels
• Air pollution hazards from improper waste incineration or gas emissions
• Failure to control hazardous spills, leaks, or explosions
3. Financial Issues
• High operational costs, making the facility financially unviable
• Loss of funding or investment due to non-compliance or economic downturns
• Lawsuits and penalties that cause financial instability
4. Technological and Infrastructure Limitations
• Outdated treatment or disposal technology failing to meet new standards
• Deteriorating facility infrastructure leading to safety risks
• Inability to upgrade equipment due to high costs
5. Community and Social Opposition
• Protests or opposition from local communities concerned about environmental and health
impacts
• Change in land-use policies favoring residential or commercial development
6. Natural Disasters and Accidents
• Floods, earthquakes, or other natural disasters causing irreparable damage
• Fires, chemical explosions, or severe contamination events making the facility unsafe
7. Voluntary Closure and Relocation
• The company decides to shut down or relocate to a more suitable or profitable location
• Transition to alternative waste treatment technologies (e.g., waste-to-energy solutions)
Importance of a proper closure:
• A closure plan is a necessary part of a permit application, thus providing a plan for final
closure prior to startup of operations.
• A closure plan provides a clear and orderly set of steps and methods to be followed upon
termination of all operations at a facility.
• The steps are designed to ensure that the closed facility:
(a) poses a minimal risk to the environment and human health, and
(b) requires minimal post-closure maintenance.
• A closure plan requires assurance that funds are available to close the facility even if the
facility owner enters bankruptcy proceedings. This assurance can be in the form of a bond,
corporate guarantee, or some other financial instrument.
• Closure of a storage or treatment facility requires removal of all remaining waste to
another facility.
• All equipment and structures that had been in contact with the waste must be
decontaminated. This may entail removal of concrete pads used to hold waste containers
as well as contaminated soil where leaks had occurred.
• The closure of land disposal facilities, where waste has been emplaced, differs from
closure of a treatment facility. In the former case, waste is not to be removed but
contained, necessitating installation of cover systems plus implementation of a long-term
plan referred to as a post-closure plan.
• This plan provides for leachate management, monitoring, maintenance, security, and other
measures typically for a period of 30 years, if not longer.
FACILITY DEVELOPMENT
a) Needs Assessment
b) Site Selection
c) Public Participation
d) Permitting
NEEDS ASSESSMENT
• The first step is to decide what type of facility is needed and its capacity.
• It is readily apparent that the ideal characteristics for a site depend upon the type and
scale of facility to be located there.
• The process for making such a decision is called NEEDS ASSESSMENT.
• A needs assessment involves an analysis of the following:
1. The current and future types and quantities of hazardous waste generated
2. The current methods for managing the generated waste
3. The methods expected or desired in the future for managing the generated waste
4. The capacity of existing facilities providing such methods
• The need for new facilities is thus determined by comparing future waste generation with
capacity of existing facilities. A shortfall in capacity indicates a need for new facilities.
SITE SELECTION
• A primary objective of a site selection process is to assure that new facilities are located at
intrinsically superior sites that, by virtue of their natural features and land use setting, provide a
high degree of protection to public health and the environment.
• In this concept, the land use setting and natural features function as an additional line of defense
if the facility operations do not perform as planned.
• A site selection process usually proceeds through a PHASED APPROACH.
✓ Phase I: It begins with the use of regional screening techniques to reduce a large study area, such
as an entire state, to a manageable number of discrete search areas. Computerized geographic
information systems (GIS) are available to assist in this task.
✓ Phase II: The next phase evaluates the discrete search areas in more detail and identifies
candidate sites within them.
✓ Phase III: These candidate sites are then evaluated in even more detail at a site-specific level of
analysis to provide the basis for selecting a site for the facility.
• The overall site selection process is thus one of increasingly intensive analysis of progressively smaller areas.
Phased Site Selection Process
Site Screening Methods
• Different methods used to integrate and evaluate data (data synthesis) in the phased
approach site selection:
a) Intuitive
b) Stepped-down exclusion
c) Scaling
d) Criteria combinations
❑ The INTUITIVE METHOD is one in which the decision maker examines all data as a whole
and judges whether the site is acceptable.
o The argument for using this method is that the site characteristics are too functionally
interdependent with (i) each other, (ii) with the design and operation of the proposed
facility, to support an assessment derived from an examination of individual factors.
• Most screening methods require siting criteria and siting criteria stem from siting factors.
• A siting factor is associated with a specific consideration important in judging the suitability
of a site.
• For eg. The potential for leachate to migrate to ground water is a consideration with land
disposal facilities. Accordingly, it is desirable that a land disposal site have one or more of the
following characteristics: the permeability of the uppermost formation is low, the depth to
ground water is high, and the thickness of any clay deposits is high. Thus, the pertinent siting
factors are permeability, depth to ground water, and thickness of clay. The factors applicable
to a treatment facility may be very different.
• A criterion is a definitive threshold of acceptability for a siting factor. For eg. a criterion for
permeability could be a maximum of 1 × 10−7 𝑐𝑚Τ𝑠𝑒𝑐. Sites having a value higher than this
would be deemed unsuitable.
• Siting criteria can be divided into two types:
a) Mandatory criteria – represent a legal requirement, a regulatory standard, or some
other aspect deemed so important that it cannot be violated under any circumstance
b) Discretionary criteria – represent desirable but not mandatory features. These reflect
preferences and value judgements.
• Narrative and Numerical criteria – example: protection of ground water from the possible
migration of leachate from a hazardous waste landfill
o A narrative criterion for permeability – “Allowed only in areas having a sufficient thickness of
naturally occurring geologic materials of low permeability (like dense bedrock) to assure that
effective remedial action can be taken”
o Numerical criterion for permeability – “A minimal thickness (eg. 20 feet) of regionally
continuous clay having a permeability no greater than 1 × 10−7 𝑐𝑚Τ𝑠𝑒𝑐.
Value Judgements and Trade-offs
• The extensive community participation in the siting process is the key to success, fostering
trust upon which understanding and acceptance could build.
• The triad of the facility developer, the local community, and the regulatory agency is
closely interrelated in the issue of siting new facilities.
• In the supportive role, government initiatives include a credible waste management plan
justifying the need for a new facility, assistance grants to proposed host communities,
extensive public information, public participation in selection of siting criteria if not the site
itself or at least the type of facility developed at the site, and a negotiated siting agreement
between the facility developer and the local community.
• To the facility developer, this level of public involvement may seem excessive to deal with.
However, experience shows that without it, an expensive and long siting process and the
high probability of regulatory denial are inevitable.
Key issues among triad of participants
in siting a facility
What can be done for successful siting?
➢ Form a committee of representatives from government and the public to develop and
implement a site selection process consisting of two parts:
a) The development and scientific application of technical siting criteria to ensure the intrinsic
suitability of the selected site
b) The resolution of sociological issues so as to foster acceptance by the host communities
➢ Meetings with municipalities, local authorities, community representatives to explain the need
for a facility, discuss planned siting process, and to receive local input. (preferably after
preparing the regional screening maps but before naming the specific sites)
➢ More local meetings and workshops to educate the community; formation of local review
committees; major objectives:
a) Engender a sense of individual responsibility for overall industrial, municipal, and household
waste problem of which hazardous waste is one small part
b) Demonstrate that the risks of a facility are no greater than those posed by other industries
➢ Strong communication program:
• Treatment, storage and disposal facilities (TSDFs) are required to obtain permission
which establishes the administrative and technical conditions under which waste at the
facility must be managed.
• A permit is a legally binding document that establishes the waste management activities
a facility can conduct and the conditions under which it can conduct them.
• Permits typically require facilities to develop emergency plans, find insurance and
financial backing, and train employees to handle hazards. Permits can also
include specific facility requirements, such as groundwater monitoring.
• The permitting agency has the authority to issue or deny permits and is responsible for
monitoring the facility.
Permitting Process for TSDFs
➢ The hazardous waste permitting process for Treatment, Storage, and Disposal Facilities
(TSDFs) in India follows the Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and
Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016, under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.
The process ensures that TSDFs are properly designed, operated, and monitored to prevent
environmental contamination.
• Although the advantages of a daily cover are clear, it is also clear that placement of
uncontaminated clean soil on a daily basis in a hazardous landfill is both expensive and
uses up landfill space.
• Also, the collection and treatment of leachate is an integral part of any hazardous waste
land disposal facility.
SITE SELECTION
• The selection of a hazardous waste disposal site is a highly charged political topic.
• From technical point of view, the site selection should incorporate considerations of geology,
hydrogeology, and hydrology.
• The natural environment of the site should exhibit characteristics that provide redundancy to
the engineered systems to protect the public health and the environment.
• For example: an area exhibiting an upward gradient from deeper aquifers would carry
contaminants (in case of a spill or leakage) away from the aquifer. Locating the landfill within
a clay formation immediately beneath the site also offers a level of natural protection.
• The intrinsic value of the site environment also needs to be considered. For example:
choosing a landfill site where the underlying ground water is unsuitable for use due to the
presence of naturally occurring chemical constituents.
• In addition to subsurface hydrology and geology, there are surface water hydrology
considerations.
• Undoubtedly, the construction of an engineered final cover will increase surface water
runoff.
• Both the sensitivity and capacity of the receiving waters to surface water runoff and to
leachate discharge after treatment require consideration.
• Streams of high value (drinking water supply source) need special consideration.
LINER AND LEACHATE COLLECTION SYSTEMS
• The purpose of a liner is to provide a barrier to minimize migration of contaminants. A liner
with 100% effectiveness will prevent chemical constituents from migrating across the liner
system into the environment.
• Because no liner is 100% effective, some leachate will be generated inevitably and thus,
leachate collection is required.
• Therefore, the landfill bottom consists of:
1. Alternating layers of materials to provide barriers to contaminants attempting to migrate
from the landfill
2. Layers providing collection of these contaminants through collection systems
• Leachate is a combination of the direct precipitation infiltration (during operational period),
and any liquids squeezed out as a result of consolidation of landfill waste materials.
• Leachate seeps downwards to the base of the landfill due to gravitational forces. Leachate may
also carry particulate material (suspended solids) along with the dissolved constituents.
• At the base of the land disposal facility, the leachate first passes through a filter zone. The
filter zone may be a geotextile, and/or well-graded sand and gravel through which the
particulates are filtered out. A geogrid may also be included to provide additional structural
stability.
• The filter separates the waste from a relatively free draining zone around the primary
leachate collection piping. In this primary leachate collection zone, the leachate is free to
flow to the piping system for removal for treatment.
• The primary barrier layer underlines the entirety of the primary leachate collection zone.
This primary barrier layer should be a synthetic material known as a geomembrane of flexible
membrane liner (FML). Both geotextiles and geomembranes are known as geosynthetics.
• In a perfect system, the leachate is stopped by the primary barrier layer and is collected
there for subsequent treatment. However, it has been observed that all liners leak.
Schematic of liner and leachate collection systems for a hazardous waste
disposal facility
• The secondary leachate collection zone functions much the same as the primary
leachate collection system and underlies the primary barrier layer. This second system is
also known as leak detection system.
• Given the effectiveness of the primary liner, the secondary leachate collection systems
handles considerably reduced quantity of leachate.
• Beneath the secondary leachate collection system is yet another geomembrane, the
second barrier layer, that acts in the same manner as the primary barrier layer,
preventing downward flow of contaminants and allowing the secondary collection system
to collect the leachate.
• Underlying the entire system of primary and secondary leachate collection and
geomembrane barriers is a third barrier, constructed of natural material, compacted clay
or clay admixed into the natural underlying soils.
• The third barrier layer is required to control contaminants that may have passed through
the secondary leachate collection system.
➢ There can be several combinations and variations for arrangement of liner and leachate
collection system.
• One such example is shown in the figure on next slide – for a MSW and industrial waste
landfill.
• It exclusively employs geosynthetics for both drainage and barrier layers.
• The filters are geotextiles, drainage layers are geonets, and barrier layers are
geomembranes and geocomposites.
• The geosynthetic clay liner is a sodium montmorillonite clay attached to a geotextile to
create a thin clay sheet of low permeability.
Schematic of geosynthetic liner and leachate collection systems
COMPOSITE SYSTEMS
• A liner designed to minimize the rate of contaminant migration into the environment must:
1. Minimize hydraulic conductivity
2. Minimize molecular diffusion rate
3. Maximize retardation
• Composite liners are made of dissimilar materials, each employed to achieve one or more of
the above goals.
• The composite liner materials include bentonite, zeolite (suitable for the inorganic
components of leachate), organically modified clays, high-carbon fly ash (suitable for organic
constituents of leachate), and geosynthetics.
• The adsorbing barrier materials can be admixed with clay or attached to the geomembranes
for reducing hydraulic conductivity. The use of these materials individually is well known for
adsorption in wastewater treatment, such as zeolites, carbon, organically modified clays.
• The adsorbing layers should be located on the underside of the secondary geomembrane
liner because the geomembranes function as the primary barrier against contaminant
transport by acting as a hydraulic barrier.
• In this way, the contaminant loading to the adsorptive layers is decreased and their useful
lives are extended.
• Figure on the next slide shows a composite liner system that incorporates both the barrier
and leachate collection system along with the materials that reduce the rate of diffusion
through the system.
• Materials that delay the transport of inorganic contaminants include calcium bentonite,
sodium bentonite, and zeolite.
• Materials that attenuate organic contaminants include high-carbon fly ash (effective for
low molecular weight organics) and organically modified clay (effective for higher
molecular weight organics).
Schematic of composite liner system for a hazardous waste disposal facility
COVER SYSTEMS
• A significant source of leachate generation at hazardous waste disposal facility is the
infiltration of water through the top of landfill, by either direct precipitation or stormwater
runoff.
• The final cover design considers health, safety, aesthetics, and site usage after closure,
coupled with engineering requirements for permeability, compressibility, and strength.
• The final cover is expected to remain in service for as long as the waste is present (30 years or
more), it must provide for the following:
✓ Control water movement into the landfill system to minimize leachate generation
✓ Control animals and vectors which can introduce disease into the ecosystem
✓ Protect the public from the results of direct contact with waste
✓ Control gas movement to avoid a decline in air quality
✓ Control surface water runoff
✓ Resist erosion
✓ Provide a more slightly appearance
Schematic of hazardous waste landfill cover
• The uppermost layer, a vegetation support layer, typically consists of an organic silty loam
(topsoil) material used to support vegetation.
• Vegetation provides several important functions in the performance of the landfill cover:
✓ Reduces erosion
✓ Reduces precipitation infiltration
✓ Enhances evapotranspiration, i.e., returning moisture that has been absorbed into the topsoil
layer into the atmosphere to further reduce deeper infiltration
• The lateral drainage layer underlies the vegetative support layer and is a free-draining
porous, gravelly material, geonet, or geocomposite. The purpose of this drainage layer is to
enhance lateral drainage of any precipitation that infiltrates through the vegetative support
zone. With proper grading of the lateral drainage layer, the infiltration can be collected.
• The lateral drainage layer and the vegetative support layer function in combination to protect
the underlying barrier layers from the environmental stresses of wetting and drying and
freezing and thawing.
• A geotextile filter may be placed beneath the topsoil and above the underlying lateral
drainage layer.
• The geotextile serves to maintain separation between the layers and to act as a filter to
minimize migration of materials, thus reducing the risk of clogging of drainage layer with topsoil
fines.
• Beneath the lateral drainage layer is one more barrier layer. The barrier layer may be
composed of any of the barriers previously discussed including geomembranes, admixed
materials, and natural clays. The barrier layer represents the final resistance to precipitation
infiltration.
• Underlying the barrier layer may be a gas collection layer used to collect generated gases
migrating from the landfill for subsequent venting to the atmosphere.
• This layer is typically composed of porous sands and gravels and may include gas collection
piping. Gases that may be generated include carbon dioxide and methane from the anaerobic
digestion of organic matter as well as volatile organics.
• Hazardous waste landfills contain significantly less organics than MSW landfills, thereby
making it impractical to collect gases for resource recovery. Nevertheless, some gases can be
expected and need to be managed.
• The lowermost layer in a landfill cover system may be a subgrade layer to accommodate
uneven and unstable landfill surfaces. This layer also aids construction of a cover with
appropriate contours needed to enhance lateral drainage.
SURFACE WATER CONTROLS
• The construction of a hazardous waste disposal facility alters the natural hydrology of the
site. Prior to construction, surface water probably flowed onto the site.
• Surface water controls for landfills are essential to prevent erosion, minimize leachate
generation, and protect surrounding water bodies from contamination.
• To control surface water, routine technologies can be incorporated into the site development
for hazardous waste disposal facilities. The technologies include surface water diversion and
collection systems to minimize any surface water entering active areas of the site.
• Surface water diversion technologies include dikes and berms, ditches and drainage ways,
terraces and benches. Surface water can also be controlled by grading and revegetation
(enhance evapotranspiration, minimize erosion, and sediment transport).
• Control of surface water continues when the final cover is constructed. Runoff from the cover
system must be managed through the techniques shown in the table.
Surface water controls for landfills
➢ Berms are raised earthen
embankments used to
control water flow and
provide structural stability.
Good resistance to corrosive chemicals; not very good for oils and solvents
• Geotextiles can be classified by the way they are manufactured as either woven or non-
woven.
✓ Woven geotextiles tend to be stronger in tension and have been used for
reinforcement.
✓ Non-woven geotextiles have been used for filtration, separation, and as a protective
layer over geomembranes.
• The durability of a geotextile for the long-term demands of a hazardous waste landfill is of
critical importance. The properties for consideration of endurance include:
o Ultraviolet light stability
o Abrasion resistance
o Chemical stability
o Thermal stability
• Generally, the durability of a geotextile is not of concern except for chemical instability.
They are protected from ultraviolet light and abrasion because they are buried. They are
protected from thermal instability because they are stable over quite a wide range of
temperatures.
• A critical issue regarding the long-term performance is the issue of clogging – how rapidly;
kind of biological activity present and its contribution to clogging?
COMPACTED CLAYS
• The exchangeable ions in the clay (i.e., Ca and Na) readily exchange with heavy metals such
as copper, nickel, and lead. Thus, as leachate migrates through a soil liner containing
bentonite, the rate of advective transport is reduced as a result of the lower hydraulic
conductivity, and the diffusive transport is reduced due to the exchange and adsorption of
metal ions onto the clay surface.
ZEOLITE
• The caged structure of the zeolite acts like a molecular sieve. Metal ions that pass into the
sieve are trapped and held by ion exchange. The five principal zeolites found in nature are
analcite, clinoptilolite, erionite, chabazite, and mordenite.
• Zeolites perform a wide range of waste management functions including purification of water
contaminated with radioactive ions, removal of ammonium from the effluent of a waste water
treatment plants, adsorption of metals from industrial wastewaters. Among the metal ions,
zeolites prefer arsenic, cadmium, and lead.
ORGANICALLY MODIFIED CLAYS
• Organically modified clays are naturally occurring clays in which a portion of the exchangeable
inorganic cations are exchanged with suitable organic cations such as quaternary ammonium.
• The reactions that exchange the organic cations with the inorganic cations on the surface of
the clay include adsorption, ion exchange, and intercalation.
• Different organically modified clays result from different base clays (eg. Montmorillonite and
attapulgite) and different organic cations used in the exchange.
• The unmodified clay is hydrophilic whereas the modified clay is organophylic and
hydrophobic.
• Organically modified clays adsorb organic molecules as a result of adsorbate interactions and
adsorbate-solvent interactions.
• The adsorption capacity of an organically modified clay is therefore dependent upon both the
properties of the organic cation used to make the organically modified clay as well as the
properties of the fluids, such as temperature, pH, and organic waste type and concentration.
FLY ASH
• Fly ash is the byproduct of the combustion of coal burned for the production of electricity.
The material is a silt-sized particulate, silicious in nature, containing various levels of
unburnt carbon.
A. Geotechnical Factors
• Slope Angle & Height: Steeper and taller
landfills are more prone to failure.
• Soil & Waste Composition: Organic waste
decomposition can lead to settlement
and instability.
• Leachate Accumulation: Excess moisture weakens the waste mass and soil, leading to landslides.
B. Environmental Factors
• Rainfall & Water Infiltration: Heavy rainfall can cause saturation and slope failure.
• Gas Generation & Pressure: Methane buildup can create internal pressure and
instability.
• Seismic Activity: Earthquakes can trigger landfill slides in high-risk zones.
C. Operational Factors
• Waste Compaction: Poor compaction can create voids, increasing instability.
• Loading & Overburden: Excessive waste piling beyond design capacity can lead to
failures.
➢ Landfill Stability Assessment Methods
4. Regulatory Framework
• US EPA (RCRA Subtitle C - Hazardous Waste Landfills)
• EU Landfill Directive (1999/31/EC)
• India’s Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management & Transboundary Movement) Rules,
2016