1 SecA

Discuss the concept of Multiculturalism in Indian Classroom with respect to Mother Tongue according to NCF-2005.
Illustrate the issues or problems of Multiculturalism in Classroom with respect to Mother Tongue.

Ans: Introduction Multiculturalism in Indian classrooms reflects the linguistic, cultural, and ethnic diversity of the country.
With over 19,500 languages and dialects spoken across India, schools often bring together students from diverse linguistic and
cultural backgrounds. The National Curriculum Framework (NCF) 2005 recognizes this diversity and emphasizes the
importance of respecting and integrating the mother tongue in education to ensure inclusive and effective learning.

Multiculturalism in Indian Classrooms

Concept of Multiculturalism

Multiculturalism refers to the coexistence and integration of diverse cultural, linguistic, and social groups in a shared space.

In the context of Indian classrooms, it acknowledges and values students’ varied cultural and linguistic backgrounds.

Definition:Bhikhu Parekh:Multiculturalism is "the acknowledgment and promotion of cultural diversity while fostering social
cohesion and mutual understanding among groups."

Charles Taylor (1994):"Multiculturalism demands that the identity of minority cultures be recognized and valued by the
majority culture, ensuring equal respect for all cultural groups."

NCF-2005 emphasizes promoting unity in diversity and fostering respect for all languages and cultures.

Role of Mother Tongue in Multicultural Classrooms (According to NCF-2005)

1. Foundation for Cognitive Development:The mother tongue is essential for a child's cognitive development, as it is the
language they are most familiar with, helping them grasp concepts more effectively.

2. Facilitates Better Comprehension:Teaching in the mother tongue ensures that students understand lessons clearly, leading
to better academic outcomes.

3. Promotes Inclusivity:Using the mother tongue in classrooms ensures that students from diverse linguistic backgrounds feel
included and valued in the learning process.

4. Strengthens Cultural Identity:Education in the mother tongue helps preserve students' cultural heritage, fostering pride
and respect for their cultural roots.

5. Encourages Active Participation:Students are more confident and active in classroom discussions when they can express
themselves in their mother tongue.

6. Bridge to Learning Additional Languages:The mother tongue serves as a foundation for learning second and third languages,
as children transfer linguistic skills from one language to another.

7. Supports the Three-Language Formula:NCF-2005 emphasizes the three-language formula, where the mother tongue or
regional language plays a crucial role alongside Hindi and English in promoting multilingualism.

8. Addresses Linguistic Diversity:In multicultural classrooms, the use of the mother tongue helps accommodate the linguistic
diversity of students, making education equitable and accessible.

These points highlight the pivotal role of the mother tongue in fostering a supportive, inclusive, and effective learning
environment in multicultural classrooms, as advocated by NCF-2005.
2 SecA

Question.Discuss the need and importance of mother language in classroom learning and its role in development of the
culture.

Ans. IntroductionThe mother language, also referred to as the first language or native language, plays a pivotal role in
classroom learning and cultural development. It serves as the foundation for a child’s cognitive, emotional, and social growth,
shaping their identity and understanding of the world. Integrating the mother tongue into education is crucial for preserving
cultural heritage and fostering inclusive learning environments.

Need for Mother Language in Classroom Instruction

1. Foundation of Learning:The mother language is the first language a child understands and uses. It provides the foundation
for learning new concepts effectively.

2. Comprehension and Clarity:Teaching in the mother tongue ensures students understand concepts clearly, leading to better
academic performance.

3. Emotional Security:Learning in the mother tongue creates a sense of familiarity and comfort, which boosts confidence and
reduces learning anxiety.

4. Inclusivity:Using the mother tongue in instruction ensures that all students, especially those from linguistic minorities, feel
included and respected.

5. Bridge to Multilingualism:A strong foundation in the mother tongue helps students learn additional languages more easily
by building transferable linguistic skills.

6. Retention and Participation:Instruction in the mother tongue reduces dropout rates and encourages active participation in
class activities.

Importance of Mother Language in Classroom Learning

1. Enhances Comprehension and Learning:Students learn and understand concepts more effectively when taught in their
mother language, as it is the language they are most familiar with.

2. Promotes Cognitive Development:The use of the mother tongue strengthens critical thinking, problem-solving, and
analytical skills, laying the groundwork for lifelong learning.

3. Builds Confidence:Children feel more comfortable and confident when they can express themselves in their native language,
leading to active participation in classroom activities.

4. Facilitates Multilingualism:A strong foundation in the mother language makes it easier for students to learn additional
languages, enhancing their linguistic abilities.

5. Reduces Dropout Rates:Teaching in the mother tongue minimizes language barriers, making education accessible and
reducing the likelihood of students dropping out of school.

6. Promotes Equity and Inclusion:Incorporating the mother language in classrooms ensures that students from diverse
linguistic backgrounds feel valued and included, fostering a sense of belonging.

7. Supports Holistic Development:The mother tongue aids in the development of emotional and social skills, as it connects
children to their families and communities.
3 SecA

8. Improves Academic Outcomes:Studies show that students perform better academically when they receive early education
in their mother language before transitioning to other languages.

Role of Mother Language in Cultural Development

1. Preservation of Cultural Heritage:The mother tongue is a carrier of traditions, customs, and values, helping students stay
connected to their cultural roots.

2. Transmission of Knowledge and Traditions:It plays a key role in passing down cultural stories, folklore, and rituals, ensuring
continuity between generations.

3. Fosters Cultural Identity:Learning and using the mother language strengthens a child’s sense of identity and pride in their
cultural heritage.

4. Promotes Social Cohesion:Shared use of the mother tongue fosters a sense of community, unity, and mutual respect
among members of the same cultural group.

5. Encourages Respect for Diversity:By valuing all mother languages in multicultural settings, students learn to appreciate and
respect linguistic and cultural diversity.

6. Strengthens Intergenerational Bonding:The mother tongue facilitates communication with older generations, helping
maintain cultural continuity and familial bonds.

7. Supports Artistic and Literary Development:Many forms of cultural expression, such as poetry, songs, and literature, are
rooted in the mother language, enriching the cultural landscape.

Conclusion The mother language is a cornerstone of classroom learning and cultural development. It fosters effective
communication, enhances academic performance, and strengthens cultural identity. By incorporating the mother tongue in
education, schools can create an inclusive environment that values diversity while ensuring the preservation and growth of
cultural heritage. Recognizing and promoting the role of the mother language is essential for holistic development and the
creation of a culturally rich and harmonious society.

Issues or Problems of Multiculturalism in Classrooms with Respect to Mother Tongue

Despite the benefits of multiculturalism and the emphasis on mother tongue in education, several challenges persist:

1. Linguistic Barriers:In multilingual classrooms, students often struggle to understand instructions or interact with peers who
speak different mother tongues.Teachers may find it difficult to cater to the linguistic needs of all students simultaneously.

2. Neglect of Regional LanguagesThe focus on English as a medium of instruction in many schools undermines regional
languages and the mother tongue, creating a disconnect for students.Children from linguistic minorities may feel alienated or
undervalued.

3. Lack of ResourcesInsufficient teaching materials and textbooks in regional or tribal languages hinder effective
implementation of mother tongue education.A lack of qualified teachers fluent in specific mother tongues further exacerbates
the problem.

4. Marginalization of Tribal LanguagesTribal and minority languages often lack official recognition, leading to their exclusion
from the classroom.This results in the cultural and linguistic marginalization of certain student groups.
4 SecA

5. Standardized Assessment IssuesNational and state-level assessments are often conducted in dominant languages,
disadvantaging students who are more proficient in their mother tongues.

6. Parental and Societal PreferencesParents often prefer English-medium education, viewing it as a path to better
opportunities, even if it compromises the child's understanding and connection to their mother tongue.

7. Teacher Training DeficienciesTeachers are not always adequately trained to handle multilingual classrooms or promote the
effective use of multiple languages.

8. Conflict Between Unity and DiversityBalancing linguistic diversity with the need for a common language for communication
and unity can create tension in multicultural classrooms.

Illustrative ExampleImagine a classroom in India where students speak Hindi, Punjabi, and Bengali as their mother tongues.
While the teacher delivers lessons in English, some students struggle due to limited proficiency in the language. Others may
excel in English but feel disconnected from their cultural roots. Without adequate resources in their respective mother
tongues or teacher support, these students may experience barriers to learning and participation.

Discuss various advantages and disadvantages of Multiculturalism in Indian Classroom.

Ans : Advantages of Multiculturalism in Indian Classrooms

1. Promotes Social Cohesion:Multiculturalism fosters respect, understanding, and collaboration among students from
different cultural backgrounds, helping them work together harmoniously.

2. Enriches Learning Experience:Exposure to diverse cultures, languages, and traditions broadens students' perspectives,
enhancing their learning experience and promoting a global outlook.

3. Encourages Tolerance and Acceptance:By interacting with peers from various cultures, students learn to appreciate
diversity and develop tolerance, reducing stereotypes and prejudices.

4. Supports Personal Growth:Students learn to adapt to and respect different ways of thinking, which helps in personal
growth and building empathy and emotional intelligence.

5. Prepares Students for Global Citizenship:Multicultural classrooms prepare students to interact in a globalized world,
equipping them with skills to navigate diverse environments and collaborate internationally.

6. Strengthens Cultural Identity:Students can maintain and celebrate their own cultural identity while learning about others,
leading to greater self-pride and cultural awareness.

7. Promotes Language Skills:Multiculturalism encourages multilingualism, where students gain proficiency in multiple
languages, enhancing cognitive abilities and communication skills.

8. Improves Critical Thinking:Exposure to different perspectives encourages critical thinking as students analyze and question
diverse viewpoints, enriching problem-solving skills.

Disadvantages of Multiculturalism in Indian Classrooms

1. Language Barriers:In a multicultural classroom, students may speak different languages, which can create communication
barriers and hinder effective learning and classroom interaction.
5 SecA

2. Integration Challenges:Students from diverse backgrounds may find it difficult to integrate socially or academically, leading
to isolation or exclusion of certain groups.

3. Cultural Conflicts:Differences in cultural norms, values, or behaviors may lead to misunderstandings, conflicts, or even
discrimination within the classroom environment.

4. Teaching Challenges:Teachers may face difficulties in addressing the varied needs of students from different cultural and
linguistic backgrounds, requiring extra effort and specialized training.

5. Imbalance in Representation:Some cultures or languages may be underrepresented or marginalized in the curriculum,

6. Stereotyping and Prejudice:If not managed properly, multiculturalism can lead to the reinforcement of stereotypes or
biases, especially if students or teachers hold preconceived notions about other cultures.

7. Emotional Strain on Students:Students who are in the minority or belong to marginalized cultural groups may feel alienated
or experience emotional distress due to cultural differences and social exclusion.

8. Resource Constraints:Schools may face challenges in providing culturally relevant teaching materials, resources, or
language support for all students, affecting the effectiveness of multicultural education.

Conclusion:Multiculturalism in Indian classrooms offers many advantages, such as promoting social cohesion, enriching
learning experiences, and preparing students for a globalized world. However, it also presents challenges, including language
barriers, cultural conflicts, and integration issues. To maximize the benefits of multiculturalism, educators and policymakers
must focus on inclusivity, cultural sensitivity, and providing appropriate resources and support for both students and teachers.

Question:Specify the role of teacher in ensuring unity in multiculturalism classroom.

Introduction In an increasingly diverse and interconnected world, classrooms are becoming more multicultural, with students
from various cultural, linguistic, and ethnic backgrounds. In such environments, ensuring unity and fostering a sense of
belonging for all students becomes a crucial aspect of effective teaching. The teacher plays a key role in creating a harmonious,
inclusive, and respectful classroom atmosphere where every student feels valued and connected, despite their differences.

Meaning of Unity in Multicultural ClassroomsUnity in multicultural classrooms refers to creating an environment where
students from diverse backgrounds respect, understand, and collaborate with each other. It means acknowledging and
celebrating differences while working toward common goals, ensuring that no student feels alienated based on their cultural
or linguistic identity. The goal is to foster a sense of community, cooperation, and mutual respect among all students, making
the classroom a place of inclusivity and shared learning.

Role of Teacher in Ensuring Unity in a Multicultural Classroom

1. Creating an Inclusive Learning Environment:The teacher’s first responsibility is to create a classroom environment where all
students feel safe, respected, and valued. This includes celebrating cultural diversity and ensuring that no student feels
excluded because of their background.

2. Encouraging Respect and Tolerance:Teachers can set the tone for respect and tolerance by addressing discriminatory
behavior, teaching students to appreciate diversity, and emphasizing the importance of kindness and empathy. Modeling
inclusive behavior is essential to promoting unity.
6 SecA

3. Building Cultural Awareness and Sensitivity:A teacher must actively work to incorporate students' cultural backgrounds
into the classroom curriculum. By acknowledging and discussing cultural differences, the teacher helps foster mutual
understanding and respect, allowing students to appreciate each other’s uniqueness.

4. Providing Equal Opportunities for All Students:It is important for teachers to ensure that all students have equal access to
classroom resources, participation opportunities, and support. This means addressing the specific needs of students, including
those from minority or disadvantaged groups, and adapting teaching strategies to meet those needs.

5. Promoting Collaborative Activities:Encouraging group work and peer learning in multicultural classrooms allows students
from different backgrounds to collaborate, learn from each other, and build relationships. Collaborative activities help break
down cultural barriers and encourage unity by focusing on shared goals.

6. Culturally Responsive Teaching:Teachers should adapt their teaching styles to be culturally responsive, using examples,
materials, and activities that reflect the diverse backgrounds of students. This promotes a deeper connection with the material
and fosters a more inclusive and engaging learning experience.

7. Addressing Conflicts and Misunderstandings:In a multicultural classroom, misunderstandings and conflicts may arise due to
cultural differences. Teachers must address these situations promptly and constructively, fostering a dialogue that helps
students understand different perspectives and resolve conflicts peacefully.

Conclusion Teachers play an integral role in ensuring unity in a multicultural classroom. By creating an inclusive and respectful
environment, promoting cultural awareness, and fostering collaboration, teachers help students appreciate diversity and build
a sense of belonging. Through their efforts, they can transform the classroom into a place where all students, regardless of
their cultural or linguistic backgrounds, feel empowered to learn, share, and grow together. This not only enhances the
learning experience but also prepares students to thrive in a diverse, global society.

Question:Enlist major recommendations or guidelines of NCEF 2005 regarding multiculturalism in classroom.

Introduction India's classrooms are diverse, with students hailing from various linguistic, cultural, and regional backgrounds.
The National Curriculum Framework (NCF) 2005 recognizes this diversity and provides guidelines for promoting
multiculturalism in education. It emphasizes the need for an inclusive and equitable education system that celebrates diversity,
fosters mutual respect, and promotes social cohesion. The NCF 2005 outlines various recommendations to ensure that
multiculturalism is effectively integrated into the classroom, empowering students from all backgrounds to thrive together.

Major Recommendations and Guidelines of NCF 2005 Regarding Multiculturalism in Classroom

1. Promotion of Linguistic Diversity:The NCF 2005 emphasizes the importance of using students’ mother tongue as a medium
of instruction, especially in the early years of schooling, to ensure better understanding and retention.

2. Inclusive Curriculum Development:The curriculum should reflect the cultural, linguistic, and regional diversity of India. It
should integrate stories, histories, and examples from different cultures and communities to make learning more relevant and
inclusive.

3. Celebration of Cultural Diversity:The NCF 2005 encourages celebrating festivals, traditions, and cultural events from various
communities to promote respect and understanding among students from different backgrounds.

4. Encouraging Multilingualism:The three-language formula (Mother Tongue, Hindi, and English) is recommended to promote
multilingualism. Students should be encouraged to learn multiple languages to enhance their cognitive and communicative
abilities.
7 SecA

5. Addressing Stereotypes and Prejudices:The NCF stresses the importance of creating an environment where negative
stereotypes, biases, and prejudices related to caste, class, gender, or culture are actively discouraged. Teachers should
promote critical thinking to counter these stereotypes.

6. Equal Access and Opportunity for All Students:The framework advocates for ensuring that all students, regardless of their
socio-economic or cultural backgrounds, have equal access to quality education and are not excluded based on their language,
religion, or ethnicity.

7. Development of Teachers’ Sensitivity to Diversity:Teachers are encouraged to be sensitive to the diverse cultural, linguistic,
and socio-economic backgrounds of their students. Teacher training programs should include modules on multicultural
education to equip teachers with the skills to handle diversity effectively.

8. Incorporating Local Knowledge and Practices:The NCF 2005 recommends incorporating local knowledge, indigenous
practices, and cultural traditions in the curriculum. This will not only make the curriculum more relevant to students but also
promote cultural pride and respect for local communities.

9. Inclusive Pedagogies:The framework highlights the use of inclusive pedagogies that recognize and respect diverse ways of
learning. Teachers are encouraged to adapt their teaching methods to accommodate the varied learning needs and styles of
students from different cultural backgrounds.

10. Encouraging Collaboration and Interaction:Multicultural classrooms should be spaces for collaborative learning. The NCF
suggests promoting group work, peer learning, and discussions to encourage students to learn from each other’s diverse
experiences and perspectives.

11. Promoting Gender Sensitivity:Multiculturalism is also linked to gender sensitivity in the classroom. The NCF emphasizes
the need to promote gender equality and challenge gender stereotypes, ensuring that both boys and girls have equal
opportunities to participate and excel in the classroom.

12. Engaging Communities in the Learning Process:The NCF encourages involving local communities in the education process.
This could involve community elders, local artisans, and cultural leaders in educational activities to bridge the gap between
school education and community knowledge.

These guidelines from the NCF 2005 aim to build an education system that is inclusive, respects diversity, and prepares
students for a globalized and multicultural world.

Conclusion

The NCF 2005 offers a comprehensive framework for fostering multiculturalism in classrooms by promoting linguistic diversity,
inclusive curricula, and an environment of respect and equality. By implementing these recommendations, educators can
create classrooms that reflect the richness of India's diversity, ensuring that all students, regardless of their cultural or
linguistic background, have equal opportunities to succeed. The guidelines encourage teachers to build a learning environment
that respects differences, celebrates diversity, and prepares students to thrive in a multicultural and interconnected world.

Question:Explain the Advantages of Learning English as a Second Language in a Multicultural Class, according to NCF 2005.

Ans IntroductionIn a multicultural classroom, students from diverse linguistic and cultural backgrounds often face challenges
in communication and understanding. The National Curriculum Framework (NCF) 2005 acknowledges the importance of
language learning in such environments, particularly the role of English as a second language. English, being a global lingua
franca, bridges the gap between students, facilitating better interaction, learning, and integration. The NCF 2005 outlines the
advantages of learning English in a multicultural classroom, highlighting how it supports cognitive development, fosters social
8 SecA

inclusion, and prepares students for a globalized world. By incorporating English into the educational process, students gain
not only language skills but also the ability to thrive in diverse, interconnected societies.

Advantages of Learning English as a Second Language in a Multicultural Class (According to NCF 2005)

1. Enhances Communication Across Cultures:English, as a global language, serves as a common medium of communication
among students from diverse linguistic backgrounds. Learning English enables students to interact with peers from different
cultures and communities, fostering greater social integration and understanding.

2. Promotes Cognitive Development:According to NCF 2005, learning English as a second language promotes cognitive
flexibility, problem-solving, and critical thinking skills. The process of learning a second language enhances memory,
concentration, and overall mental agility, which contributes to a student’s academic growth.

3. Bridges Language Barriers:In multicultural classrooms where students speak different languages, English serves as a bridge
to connect them. It provides a common platform for understanding lessons, sharing ideas, and collaborating on projects, thus
ensuring that language does not become a barrier to learning.

4. Supports Global Competence:The NCF 2005 emphasizes the importance of preparing students for a globalized world.
Learning English allows students to access global knowledge, participate in international discourse, and engage with global
cultures, making them more competitive in the global job market.

5. Improves Academic Performance:English is often the medium of instruction in higher education, and proficiency in the
language improves students’ ability to excel in academic pursuits. The NCF 2005 highlights that students who are proficient in
English are better positioned to perform well in exams and research activities, as it enhances their reading, writing, and
comprehension skills.

6. Cultural Exposure and Awareness:Learning English exposes students to a wide range of global literature, media, and
cultural expressions. This exposure broadens their horizons, helping them develop a better understanding and appreciation of
different cultures, perspectives, and worldviews, which is crucial in a multicultural setting.

7. Fosters Social Inclusion: English proficiency allows students from different cultural backgrounds to feel included in the
academic and social aspects of the classroom. It reduces feelings of alienation or exclusion, as students can express
themselves and engage in class discussions with their peers, regardless of their native language.

8. Promotes Multilingualism:According to the NCF 2005, learning English does not replace the importance of a student’s
mother tongue but rather complements it. English proficiency enhances a student’s overall linguistic abilities, making it easier
for them to learn other languages and become multilingual, which is an asset in multicultural environments.

9. Improves Career Opportunities:Proficiency in English opens up a wider range of career opportunities, both within India and
internationally. The NCF 2005 recognizes that English is a key language in business, science, technology, and diplomacy, and
learning it as a second language increases employability and professional prospects.

ConclusionThe NCF 2005 emphasizes the significant advantages of learning English as a second language in a multicultural
classroom. It not only enhances communication and academic performance but also fosters cognitive development, social
inclusion, and cultural awareness. By promoting English language learning, students are better prepared for a globalized world,
where language proficiency is a vital tool for both personal and professional success.

Question:Write three basic functions of language.

Ans:Three Basic Functions of Language

1. Communication Function:The primary function of language is communication. It allows individuals to express thoughts,
ideas, emotions, and information to others. Through verbal or written forms, language facilitates understanding between
people, whether in personal conversations, public speaking, or written correspondence.

2. Cognitive Function:Language plays a crucial role in cognitive development. It helps individuals think, organize their thoughts,
solve problems, and make sense of the world around them. Language allows for abstract thinking, memory retention, and
categorization, which are essential for learning and intellectual growth.

3. Social Function:Language serves as a tool for social interaction. It helps individuals build relationships, establish identities,
and maintain social norms within a community. Through language, people engage in social rituals, express emotions, and form
connections, fostering cooperation and social cohesion.

4. Expressive Function:Language allows individuals to express their emotions, feelings, and personal experiences. This function
enables people to convey joy, sadness, anger, love, or any other emotion, thereby promoting self-expression and emotional
connection.

5. Directive Function:Language is used to influence others' actions or behaviors. Through commands, requests, or suggestions,
people use language to guide, direct, or persuade others. This function is essential in both personal and professional settings,
where instructions and guidance are needed.

6. Metalinguistic Function:Language can be used to discuss or analyze itself. This function refers to the ability of language to
provide information about its structure, rules, and usage. It is particularly important in language education, grammar
instruction, and linguistic analysis.

7. Phatic Function:Language is often used to establish or maintain social relationships rather than to convey information. This
includes greetings, small talk, and ritualized exchanges like "How are you?" or "Have a good day." These interactions serve to
create and maintain bonds, even when no substantial information is exchanged.

8. Performative Function: Language can be used to perform actions or bring about changes in the world. For instance, saying
"I promise" or "I declare" can make something happen or create a social reality. This function is common in legal, ceremonial,
or formal settings where specific statements carry official weight.
10 SecA

1. Communication Function:The primary function of language is communication. It allows individuals to express thoughts,
ideas, emotions, and information to others. Through verbal or written forms, language facilitates understanding between
people, whether in personal conversations, public speaking, or written correspondence.

2. Cognitive Function:Language plays a crucial role in cognitive development. It helps individuals think, organize their thoughts,
solve problems, and make sense of the world around them. Language allows for abstract thinking, memory retention, and
categorization, which are essential for learning and intellectual growth.

3. Social Function:Language serves as a tool for social interaction. It helps individuals build relationships, establish identities,
and maintain social norms within a community. Through language, people engage in social rituals, express emotions, and form
connections, fostering cooperation and social cohesion.

4. Expressive Function:Language allows individuals to express their emotions, feelings, and personal experiences. This function
enables people to convey joy, sadness, anger, love, or any other emotion, thereby promoting self-expression and emotional
connection.

5. Directive Function:Language is used to influence others' actions or behaviors. Through commands, requests, or suggestions,
people use language to guide, direct, or persuade others. This function is essential in both personal and professional settings,
where instructions and guidance are needed.

6. Metalinguistic Function:Language can be used to discuss or analyze itself. This function refers to the ability of language to
provide information about its structure, rules, and usage. It is particularly important in language education, grammar
instruction, and linguistic analysis.

7. Phatic Function:Language is often used to establish or maintain social relationships rather than to convey information. This
includes greetings, small talk, and ritualized exchanges like "How are you?" or "Have a good day." These interactions serve to
create and maintain bonds, even when no substantial information is exchanged.

8. Performative Function: Language can be used to perform actions or bring about changes in the world. For instance, saying
"I promise" or "I declare" can make something happen or create a social reality. This function is common in legal, ceremonial,
or formal settings where specific statements carry official weight.
11 SecA