Intern Report 1
Intern Report 1
Internship Report on
Nitrogen-doped Ni-MOF
co-doped with
Mxene/Graphene for
supercapacitor
applications
Submitted By:
A.Ravivarma
K.Abhijith
M.DineshVenkat
Md.Musharraf Ismail
-pg. 1
2
CERTIFICATE
-pg. 2
1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We would also like to give our special thanks to B. Dinesh, for giving us
the opportunity to do this Internship. It was a great learning experience
in the field of chemical research.
-pg. 1
2
CONTENTS
1. Abstract…………..... 2-3
2. Motivation……………..3
3. Introduction……………3-8
4. Literature…………..... 8-12
5. Materials and Methods……….12-15
Materials
Experimental procedure
6. Result and Analysis………….....15-42
7. Conclusion ………….....42-43
8. References………….....43-44
1. ABSTRACT
2. MOTIVATION
3. INTRODUCTION
Rising energy demand, increasing integration of renewable energy, and the
need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions have made energy storage of paramount importance.
The energy storage technology that fills the space between conventional capacitors and
batteries is known as a supercapacitor, often referred to as an ultracapacitor or an
electrochemical capacitor. High power density, quick charge and discharge speeds, and long
cycle life are all features they provide. Supercapacitors are divided into different categories
according to their working voltage, electrolyte composition, and electrode material. ( Electric
Double-Layer Capacitors (EDLCs),Pseudocapacitors,Hybrid Supercapacitors etc .).
-pg. 3
4
Researchers are actively studying different synthesis methods, electrode structures and
electrolyte systems to optimize the performance of MOF-based supercapacitors. The goal is to
achieve higher energy densities, faster charge/discharge rates, and improved overall device
performance. Although challenges remain, MOF's unique properties make it a promising
candidate for next-generation supercapacitors for applications such as portable electronics,
electric vehicles, and renewable energy systems.
The porous structure of MOFs is one of their distinguishing features. MOF pores can be
divided into two categories: permanent pores and non-permanent pores. Metal ions and organic
ligands are arranged to form permanent pores, which continue to exist long after the presence
of visitor molecules has been eliminated. However, the presence of visitor molecules causes
non-permanent pores to develop.
The huge surface area of MOFs in supercapacitors is one of its main advantages. There are
plenty of sites for the adsorption and storage of ions in MOFs, which can have surface areas
per gramme ranging from hundreds to thousands of square metres. improved energy storage
-pg. 4
5
Due to their usual low electrical conductivity, MOFs may not be suitable for use as effective
electrode materials in supercapacitors. Low conductivity can lead to excessive internal
resistance, which lowers the supercapacitor's overall performance and power output. When
exposed to water or aqueous electrolytes, many MOFs can degrade or undergo structural
changes. Due to the safety and environmental benefits of aqueous-based supercapacitors, this
restricts their application in such devices. The supercapacitor's lifespan and performance may
be affected by the instability. Although MOFs have large surface areas and pore volumes,
they often have lower energy densities than other electrode materials like carbon-based
materials or transition metal oxides (the amount of energy stored per unit mass or volume).
Their use in high-energy-density supercapacitors, which are necessary for several applications,
is hampered by this constraint.
Despite these drawbacks, research is still being done to solve these problems and enhance the
performance of MOF-based supercapacitors. To get beyond these restrictions and realise
MOFs' full potential in energy storage applications, techniques like doping MOFs with
conductive materials, creating novel MOF structures, and investigating hybrid electrode
topologies are being investigated.
A description of MXenes :
MXenes were initially identified in 2011 and are a class of 2D transition metal carbides,
nitrides, and carbonitrides. In the layered ternary compounds known as MAX phases, M
stands for an early transition metal, A for an element from Group 13 or 14, and X for
carbon and/or nitrogen, they are generated from. The A element in MAX phases is
selectively etched to create MXenes, which have a layered structure with a large surface
area and great electrical conductivity.
Expanding our knowledge of MXenes' characteristics, creating scalable synthesis
techniques, investigating novel functionalizations, and increasing their potential for use
-pg. 5
6
are the main goals of current research. MXenes continue to pioneer the way for
improvements in energy storage thanks to their amazing mix of electrical conductivity,
high surface area, and chemical stability.
High conductivity: The metallic conductivity of MXenes makes charge transport into
supercapacitor electrodes efficient. Rapid charge and discharge rates are made possible by
this property, which improves power density.
Large Surface Area: MXenes have a large specific surface area, which is commonly
measured in the hundreds to thousands of square metres per gramme. This large surface area
gives electrolyte ions plenty of room to adsorb, improving energy storage capacity.
Tunable Interlayer Spacing: By managing the etching process, the interlayer spacing of
MXenes can be changed. The integration of different electrolyte ions is made possible by
this tunability, increasing the overall capacitance and energy storage capacity of
supercapacitors.
In conclusion, the use of MXenes and MOFs in the electrode design of supercapacitors has
enormous promise for producing high-performance energy storage systems. MXenes and
MOFs open the door to the creation of new supercapacitors with increased energy and power
densities, longer cycle times, and higher overall performance thanks to their synergistic
effects, greater stability, variable pore diameters, and multifunctional electrode designs.
-pg. 6
7
In the experimental procedure, we took Metal Nitrate as the precursor material and ThioUrea
as the dopant (containing S-N atoms). Followed by Methanol as Solvent and 2-MIM
(MethylImidazole).
Adding thio urea to metal nitrate MOFs has a number of benefits and functionalization
possibilities. First off, the inclusion of sulfur atoms in thiourea molecules can add more
coordination sites for metal ions within the MOF framework, potentially improving the
structural stability and catalytic activity. Second, the distinct electronic and steric
characteristics of thio urea can have an impact on the MOF's physical characteristics,
including its porosity, surface area, and thermal stability. It is feasible to add additional
functionality and enhance the performance of MOFs in a number of applications by doping
them with thio urea.
Thiourea has been successfully incorporated into MOFs in recent studies, demonstrating the
economic potential of this doping technique. Thio urea-doped MOFs, for instance, have
demonstrated increased catalytic activity in a variety of activities, such as organic
transformations and gas adsorption procedures. Improved reaction speeds and selectivity can
result from the inclusion of thio urea moieties inside the MOF structure, which can enable
certain interactions with reactant molecules.
Thio urea doping additionally provides the chance to modify the MOF's electrical and steric
characteristics, affecting its porosity, surface area, and thermal stability. For applications like
gas adsorption and separation, where the addition of thio urea can improve the MOF's
capacity to selectively trap particular gases or molecules, these alterations can be extremely
important.
Numerous research have successfully incorporated thio urea into MOFs, demonstrating the
efficacy of this doping method. In comparison to undoped MOFs, thio urea-doped MOFs
-pg. 7
8
have shown higher catalytic activity, increased gas adsorption capabilities, and changed
selectivity. These results show how thio urea doping can be used to modify the
characteristics of MOFs for use in catalysis, gas storage, sensing, and drug delivery.
4. LITERATURE WORK.
-pg. 8
9
S.No Title of the article Synthesis Electrolyte Specific Energy density Power
method used capacitance density
1. In situ synthesis In-situ Potassium 1160.5 F/g 48.2 Wh/kg 750 W/kg
of M (Fe, Cu, Co, synthesis hydroxide at 1 A/g
and Ni)- (KOH)
MOF@MXene
composites for
enhanced specific
capacitance and
cyclic stability in
supercapacitor
electrodes
4. In Situ Growth of Hydrothermal Potassium 497.6 F/g at 223.9 Wh/kg 1953 W/kg
Ni-MOF Method hydroxide 0.5 A/g
Nanorods Array (KOH)
on Ti3C2Tx
Nanosheets for
super capacitive
Electrodes
-pg. 9
10
-pg. 10
11
-pg. 11
12
-pg. 12
13
Procedure followed:
-pg. 13
14
Cs = I.Δt /(m.ΔV)
where
-pg. 14
15
6. RESULTS
XRD(X-Ray Diffraction) :
-pg. 15
16
from minerals and metals to organic molecules and complex materials. In domains
including materials science, solid-state physics, chemistry, geology, and others where
comprehending the arrangement of atoms is important, XRD is a vital tool.
GCD :
Voltage Profile: The plot may show clearly defined plateaus or regions where the potential
is stable for a while before varying. These plateaus frequently coincide with particular
electrochemical processes like adsorption, desorption, or electrochemical reactions taking
place at the electrode interface.
Transient Periods: These times are when the potential is rapidly changing. The kinetics of
electrochemical processes, such as the charging or discharging of capacitive components,
can be learned from these transient periods.
For examining the behavior of the electrochemical system under particular
circumstances, these regions might be of interest. Sharp changes or peaks in the potential
can signify particular electrochemical events or reactions taking place in the system, like
the beginning of redox reactions or phase transitions.
-pg. 16
17
Data analysis: To learn more about capacitance, faradaic reactions, electrode kinetics, and
other electrochemical parameters, researchers frequently use GCD plots. The potential
profile's slope or curve can reveal details about the system's behavior. Keep in mind that
the interpretation of the plot can change depending on the particular experimental design,
the kind of electrochemical system being studied, and the study's objectives.
3e ni (s-n) mof
-pg. 17
18
3e ni(s-n) rgo 2%
-pg. 18
19
co s-n mof
-pg. 19
20
-pg. 20
21
ni mof 1% mxene
-pg. 21
22
ni mof rgo 1%
-pg. 22
23
ni sn 0.5 % rgo
-pg. 23
24
ni sn mxene .5 %
-pg. 24
25
ni(s-n) 2% mxene
CV :
Peak Potential: The term "peak potential" refers to the potential at which a peak occurs.
This can reveal details about the species' redox potential that are involved in
electrochemical reactions.
-pg. 25
26
It has an impact on the CV plot's peak positions and shapes. Slower scan rates could
provide more information on intricate electrochemical processes.
Reverse Scan: The potential is frequently reversed after the forward scan is finished, and
this is when the "reverse scan" starts. The current varies as the potential returns to its initial
potential, as shown by the reverse scan. This gives us more details about how reversible
the electrochemical reactions are.
Analysis: To learn more about the redox potentials, electron transfer kinetics, reaction
mechanisms, and electrochemical characteristics of the systems under study, researchers
analyze CV plots.
Always keep in mind that interpreting a CV plot can be challenging, particularly when
working with a variety of electrochemical reactions and experimental setups. For accurate
interpretation, knowledge of electrochemistry and the particular system under study is
essential.
-pg. 26
27
3e ni (s-n) mof
-pg. 27
28
3e ni(s-n) rgo 2%
-pg. 28
29
co s-n mof
-pg. 29
30
-pg. 30
31
ni mof 1% mxene
-pg. 31
32
ni mof rgo 1%
-pg. 32
33
ni sn 0.5 % rgo
-pg. 33
34
ni sn mxene .5 %
-pg. 34
35
ni(s-n) 2% mxene
SAMPLE
CODE Area Scan Rate (mV/s) mass (g) V2-V1 Specific Capacitance (F/g)
Ni (s-n)
MOF 4.18E-04 5 0.0084 0.6 1.66E+01
Ni (s-n)
MOF 8.37E-04 10 0.0084 0.6 1.66E+01
Ni (s-n)
MOF 0.00113 20 0.0084 0.6 11.21031746
Ni (s-n)
MOF 1.30E-03 50 0.0084 0.6 5.16E+01
Ni (s-n)
MOF 0.00142 100 0.0084 0.6 2.817460317E+01
ni(s-n) rgo
2% 6.50E-04 5 0.0029 0.6 7.47E+01
-pg. 35
36
Ni(s-n) 2%
mxene 1.37E-03 5 0.0013 0.6 2.2E+02
Ni(s-n) 2%
mxene 2.04E-03 10 0.0013 0.6 1.90E+02
Ni(s-n) 2%
mxene 0.0025 20 0.0013 0.6 160.2564103
Ni(s-n) 2%
mxene 0.00292 50 0.0013 0.6 74.87179487
Ni(s-n) 2%
mxene 0.00314 100 0.0013 0.6 40.25641026
ni sn
mxene .5
% 7.20E-04 5 0.0561 0.6 4.28E+01
ni sn
mxene .5
% 9.40E-04 10 0.0561 0.6 2.79E+01
ni sn
mxene .5
% 0.00114 20 0.0561 0.6 1.693404635
ni sn
mxene .5
% 0.00135 50 0.0561 0.6 0.8021390374
ni sn
mxene .5
% 0.0015 100 0.0561 0.6 0.4456327986
ni sn 0.5 %
rgo 4.64E-04 5 0.0432 0.6 3.58E+01
ni sn 0.5 %
rgo 4.58E-04 10 0.0432 0.6 1.77E+01
ni sn 0.5 %
rgo 5.28E-04 20 0.0432 0.6 1.02E+00
ni sn 0.5 %
rgo 7.85E-04 50 0.0432 0.6 6.06E-01
ni sn 0.5 %
rgo 0.00111 100 0.0432 0.6 0.4282407407
Ni MOF
Rgo 1% 1.20E-03 5 0.0446 0.6 8.97E+01
Ni MOF 7.55E-04 10 0.0446 0.6 2.82E+01
-pg. 36
37
Rgo 1%
Ni MOF
Rgo 1% 8.39E-04 20 0.0446 0.6 1.57E+01
Ni MOF
Rgo 1% 1.17E-03 50 0.0446 0.6 8.74E-01
Ni MOF
Rgo 1% 0.00159 100 0.0446 0.6 0.5941704036
Ni MOF 1%
mxene 4.44E-04 5 0.048 0.6 7.08E+01
Ni MOF 1%
mxene 5.47E-04 10 0.048 0.6 5.90E+01
Ni MOF 1%
mxene 6.85E-04 20 0.048 0.6 4.19E+01
Ni MOF 1%
mxene 9.03E-04 50 0.048 0.6 1.27E+01
Ni MOF 1%
mxene 0.0011 100 0.048 0.6 0.3819444444
XRD Analysis :
X-ray diffraction (XRD) is a flexible scientific technique that can be used to investigate the
configuration of atoms or molecules in crystalline materials. It provides insightful details
about the properties, atomic makeup, and crystal structure of a broad variety of materials,
including organic molecules, complex materials, minerals, and metals. X-ray diffraction
(XRD) is an essential technique in many fields, such as materials science, solid-state
physics, chemistry, geology, and others where understanding atom arrangement is crucial.
X-ray diffractometry's fundamental principle is based on how X-rays interact with atoms
arranged in a crystal lattice. When an X-ray beam is directed towards a crystalline sample,
the atoms in the crystal lattice diffract or scatter the X-rays. A characteristic diffraction
pattern is formed as a result of the X-ray waves aligning and reinforcing one another
through the process of constructive interference.
-pg. 37
38
Sample Notations :
In the given sample, we observe that thio-urea(N-doping) has been doped to nickel
nitrate(precursor) and was composited with 0.5% of RGO(reduced graphene oxide).And,
from the XRD-plot we notice a large sharp peak at an angle of 11 degrees(2theta) and a
few sharp peaks at 16 degrees, 22 degrees and 26 degrees. From the research articles we
have gone through, we observed nitrogen doped Ni-MOFs at angles 20-25 degrees.
-pg. 38
39
From the XRD-plot, we were able to match the peaks with the standard data from the
articles and ensure the presence of nitrogen doped Ni-MOF.
Then, we also observe peaks at 26 degrees and 37 degrees which shows the presence of
RGO. It matches with the peaks that are evident from the research articles where RGO
peaks form between 24-26 degrees.
Similarly, the XRD-plot of this sample shows small yet broad peaks at around 11 degrees
and 30 degrees. Which is more or less the same as sample 1. But, we can observe a slight
shift in the peak positions towards the right, this scenario is due to the presence of more
free electrons which increases the angle of diffraction.
So, we can ensure the presence of N-doped Ni-MOF and RGO from the above peaks of the
XRD-plot.
In this sample, though the precursor material and dopant remain same i.e., Nickel Nitrate
and Thio-urea, we dissolved 0.5% of Mxene in it, so as to form a composite material.
From the plot, we observe small and sharp peak at around 13 degrees, which ensures us the
presence of N-doped Ni-MOF
Then, we observe a few more peaks at 21 degrees, 26 degrees and 33 degrees. From the
articles we have gone through, we noticed doped MOF with Mxene as a composite showed
peaks on XRD-plot between 20-40 degrees.So, we were able to match with the standard
peaks and conclude the presence of N-doped Ni-MOF and Mxene in the given sample.
-pg. 39
40
Following the trend, the XRD-plot of the sample gave us peaks at around 11 degrees, 31
degrees.
The first peak at 11 degrees corresponds to the presence of N-doped Ni-MOF, whereas the
second peak at 31 degrees shows us the presence of Mxene in the sample.
Also, we noticed that, with increase in the concentration of Mxene, the position of the
peaks shifted slightly towards right, indicating that the presence of more free electrons thus
resulting in more angular diffraction.
From the XRD-plot, we notice small peaks at around 13 degrees and 27 degrees.
Upon studying various research papers, we came to know that, the sodium selenium doped
Ni-MOFs showed peaks on the XRD between 25-45 degrees.The first peak formed in low
angle region ensures the presence of Ni-MOF, whereas the second peak formed at 27
degrees ensures the presence of sodium selenium(Na-Se) in the given sample.
-pg. 40
41
From the results obtained from the above-mentioned tests, it can be stated
that different values of the specific capacitance were obtained for the same sample if the
Scan rate(mV/s) is changed from 5 to 100mV/s.The main aim of conducting these tests is
to figure out the scan rate at which we could get the maximum specific capacitance
value.In that aspect,the following are the conclusions made for each of the sample taken:
Ni(SN) MOF at the scan rate of 5 and 10mV/s has a specific capacitance
value of 16.6F/g.Next,Co thiourea MOF at the scan rate of 5mV/s has a specific
capacitance value of 19.9F/g. Similar to the other samples, Ni thiourea 0.5% mxene has
42.9F/g at the scan rate of 5mV/s.Ni thiourea with 1% mxene has 70.8F/g at the scan rate
of 5mV/s.Ni thiourea.2% mxene Ni thiourea mof had a value of specific capacitance
220F/g at the scan rate of 5mV/s .Similarly with RGO MOF composites .
The specific capacitance for Ni thiourea MOF with RGO 0.5% at the scan
rate of 5mV/s is 35.8 F/g And for Ni thiourea with RGO 1% is 89F/g at the scan rate of
5mV/s.Finally, the scan rate of Ni thiourea with 2% RGO for which the maximum value of
the specific capacitance is recorded is 74.7F/g at 5mV/s.
-pg. 41
42
7. CONCLUSION:
In this process of developing a suitable material for synthesizing the electrode
material for supercapacitors, various research papers were referred and the most suitable
precursor materials and the suitable dopants were selected for the desired result. the Ni
MOF is selected and it is incorporated with the Mxene and RGO materials with various
compositions namely 0.5%,1%, and 2% respectively. So finally after undergoing various
papers, the synthesizing method was selected and the doping material was selected as the
thiourea. Then the characterization techniques namely XRD, CV, and GCD were
conducted on these samples, and the final outputs from the tests were noted down for the
desired selection of material for supercapacitor applications from the observations we
received from the outputs of the tests, it can be concluded that Ni thiourea MOF with 2%
Mxene has a specific capacitance of 220F/g which is quite useful in supercapacitor
applications.So from our observations and this part of research, we can suggest that this
material can be selected as the electrode material for supercapacitor applications.
But we cannot come to the final understanding that this material can be selected
-pg. 42
43
as the material for supercapacitor applications directly with these results. More research
has to be done on the synthesized materials other than the ones which were did in this work
to come to the final conclusions. Some other tests like scanning electron microscopy
(SEM) transmission electron microscopy(TEM), cyclic stability tests and similar tests
need to be done for the final output in this regard.
8. REFERENCES :
3. Yi Peng, Yang Bai, Chunli Liu, Shuai Cao, Qingquan Kong, Huan Pang,
4. Tian, D., Wang, C. and Lu, X. (2021), “Metal–Organic Frameworks and Their Derived
Functional Materials for Supercapacitor Electrode Application”. Adv. Energy Sustainability,
https://doi.org/10.1002/aesr.202100024
-pg. 43
44
5. Sheng Qiang Zheng, Siew Shee Lim, Chuan Yi Foo, Choon Yian Haw, Wee Siong Chiu, Chin
Hua Chia, Poi Sim Khiew,”Facile synthesis of nanostructured sodium and MoS2 incorporated
Ni-MOFs with excellent cyclic durability for symmetric supercapacitor application”,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nxnano.2023.100031
6. Qunruo Pan, Min Yang, Fangxiang Song, Zhongtao Xiong, Xianping He,
7. Shenna Fu, Li Ma, Mengyu Gan, Xiuling Zhang, Tingting Li, Wang Zhan, Fei Xie,”Co-doped
nickel sulfide (NiS2) derived from bimetallic MOF for high-performance asymmetric
supercapacitors”, Synthetic Metals, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.synthmet.2021.116972
8. A.A. Bhoite, K.V. Patil, R.S. Redekar, P.S. Patil, V.A. Sawant, N.L. Tarwal,
“Solvothermal synthesis of binder free Ni-MOF thin films for supercapacitor electrodes”, Journal
of Solid State Chemistry, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jssc.2023.124192
10. Xiaoqin Wang, Nana Yang, Qiaoqin Li, Fan He, Yufei Yang, Bohua Wu, Jia Chu, Anning
Zhou, Shanxin Xiong,”Solvothermal synthesis of flower-string-like NiCo-MOF/MWCNT
composites as a high-performance supercapacitor electrode material”,Journal of Solid State
Chemistry, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jssc.2019.07.0
-pg. 44
45
-pg. 45
46
-pg. 46
47
-pg. 47