On February 11th, 2023, the defendant Jane Doe was seen causing a nuisance in the public.

The
nuisance she participated in was damaging the private property of the landlord Jake Roe. Jak�
Roe owns a small business on 3050 Garden st, Whitby, ON, L1R2G7 in the same plaza as the
Town of Whitby bylaw enforcement services office. At 3pm on that very day, Jane Doe got into
an argument with the property owner and walked outside the property and began hitting the
property with a brick. It was around 3:30pm when she stopped because she saw the Bylaw
enforcement vehicle pull into the shared parking lot. I saw Jane Doe damaging the small
business and quickly made my way to the business. When I got out my vehicle there were many
witnesses taking videos and pictures of the scene, I talked to the defendant, and she gave me
her information and told me that she damaged the property because she was angry that the
owner of the small business had run out of muffins in the store. I let Jane Doe go home and
went and talked to the small business owner and he told me that Jane Doe was a regular
customer at the store and that she got angry because his shop ran out of muffins, he told me
that she was upset about that and began damaging the outside of his shop with a brick. I asked
the property owner if he had surveillance cameras at his property and he took me to the back
where I took copies of the video in which .lane Doe is seen damaging 1\/lr. Roe's property and is
seen arguing with him minutes prior to damaging his property. I also took his witness statement
and talked to another witness named Lily Gibbons from who I received an affidavit from in
regards to her witness of the incident. I then took some pictures of the scene for evidence. On
February 15th, I visited Mr. Roe's property again, where I asked him for his business license for
his small business, 1\/lr. Roe gave me the information I needed. After putting together all the
evidence, on Feb 17th, 2023, at 2pm, I issued Jane the certificate of offence
Property of Town of Whitby 34

It is Saturday February nth'2023, the weather conditions outside are good, no rain or snow. At

15:30 I arrived at 3050 garden st Whitby, ON, L1R 2G7 in the Town vehicle where I witnessed

a woman actively causing damage to a small business shop. The lady noticed my vehicle pull into

the parking tot and stopped causing damage to the store. As I got outside my vehicle, I noticed a

Large crowd of people taking pictures and videos of the lady, I walked up to her and asked her

If everything was alright and why she was damaging the store. She dropped the brick she was

Using to damage the front windows and door of the property and walked over to me. I asked her

For her name and address and wrote that information down. She began telling me that at she was

very angry with the store owner because she was a regular customer at the shop, and they ran out

Of her favorite blueberry muffins. The store owner told her to come back tomorrow, and this made

her upset which resulted in her going outside and picking up a brick off the sidewalk of the store

And using that to hit and damage the property. She stated that she arrived around 15:00 and had

Started using the brick to damage the store sometime around 15:10.1 could tell Jane was very

Upset when she was telling me her story, so I told her that I had all the information I needed and

Sent her on her way home. I saw her walk to her vehicle which was parked right in front of the

Shop that she damaged. I took an image of her vehicle plate number and then went into the shop
Property of Town of Whitby 35

To speak with the shop owner. The shop owner is Jake Roe, and he began telling me that around

15:00, Jane came into the store and was waiting in line. She did not seem bothered by anything.

When it was time to serve her, she asked for a blueberry muffin. Mr. Roe told Jane that they ran out

Of the blueberry muffins and she began screaming at him saying that she wants her muffin and he

Needs to go bake her one immediately. When Mr., Roe told Jane he was unable to do that, she

Became furious and stormed out of the store. He said before he knew it, she was standing outside

his store windows with a brick in her hands. Mr. Roe said she began hitting his windows and front

Door resulting in major damage to his property. He yelled at her to stop but he said she refused.

Mr. Roe said he was seconds away from calling the police for help when he saw me pull into the

Parking lot and Jane stopped causing damage to his property. I then asked Mr. Roe if he had any

Cameras at his property. He took me to his office where he showed me that he had two cameras

At his property, one inside the store and one outside the store. We looked through the surveillance

Footage together in which I saw Jane Doe arguing with Mr. Roe inside the shop at 15:00 and saw

her go outside and pick up a brick and start damaging his property at 15:11 until 15:30.1 asked

Mr. Roe for copies of the footage and he gave me two USBs with both footages. 1 footage of

Jane arguing with him in the store and the other of her causing the damage outside the store.
Property of Town of Whitby 36

It was 16:05 when I asked Mr. Roe to sit down and please take a few minutes to provide me with

a witness statement as the incident is still fresh on his mind. He did so immediately, and I took that

With me. When I went back into the front of the store, I came across another witness named Lily

Gibbons, she told me she witnessed everything as she was present at the shop during the incident,

I asked her if she would like to give me a witness statement, but she said she would be unable to

Attend court or any kind of court procedure because she is unable to get time off work for it. I

Asked Lily if she had time to go to the court with me today and see if we can get her witness

Statement sworn before the courts. Lily agreed and so at 16:30, she met me at the courthouse

In Oshawa on 456 king street North, L10 5H7 and I got an affidavit from her that detailed what

She had witnessed at 3050 garden st in Whitby earlier that day between 15:00-15:30.1 thanked

Lily for her help and went back to the damaged property and took some images of the damage

Done to the property. It is Wednesday February 15th' 2023, the weather outside is windy, no rain

Or snow. I am driving the town vehicle to make a call with Jake Roe at 3050 garden st Whitby,

ON, L1R 2G7. It is 11:00 and I have finished talking to Jake Roe, my visit to him was because I

Needed a business license from him for his store that was damaged a couple of days ago on

February 11th, 2023. Mr. Roe provided me with the information I needed from him. It is now Friday
Property of Town of Whitby 37

February 17th, 2023. I attended Jane Doe house at 123 Barn street

and I gave her the certificate of offence.

Image of Jane Doe's Drivers License with her address on it. Picture was taken at the time of the
incident.
Image captured of the door to the store. The damages seen are caused by Jane Doe. Image was
taken at 16:53 on February 112023 at 3050 garden st, Whitby ON, L1R 2G7.
Image captured of the front of the store. The damage was caused by Jane Doe and the image
was taken at 16:53 on February 11 2023 at 3050 garden st, Whitby ON, L1R 2G7.
 ^
i?i^^-^^^^??t?:;^^i ^;'%^t^^%^
•:"T^:

^
''fi
?,l;3t;^i|i%-%'i£^^;
'SSsS^S^MS^.. s
Si&s? S3SSSS9&
•as^y^

•"ssag

Image of brick used by Jane doe to cause damage to Mr. Roe's Property at 16:46 on February 11
2023 at 3050 garden st, Whitby ON, L1R 267.
 VIDEO FROM THE CAMERA OUTSIDE THE
STORE. Video captures Jane Doe picking up a
brick and damaging Mr. Roe's property from
15:11 until 15:30.

VIDEO FROM THE CAMERA WITHIN THE STORE.

Video captures Jane Doe arguing with Mr. Roe
about the blueberry muffin not being in stock
from 15:00 until she leaves store at 15:11 to
start damaging property with the brick.
 VOLUNTARY WITNESS STATEMENT FORM
@EililiiiSiliM®iiEii%s£lt)E0CE
2911 E SUNSET RD, LAS VEGAS, NV 89120
Phone: 702-455-4191 -Fax: 702-455-2080
[email protected]

CASE NUMBER: 123445 OFFICER: sonia Naseer CE#:

DATE OF INCIDENT:FEBRUARY 11 , 2023

NATURE OF INCIDENT - INCLUDE ADDRESS OR LOCATION

Today is Feb 11, 2023. At 15:00 i had a customer come to my store

located at 3050 Garden st, Whitby, ON. L1 R 2G7 and she ordered a
blueberry muffin. I told her that i did not have this item in stock and
she grew angry at me. She demanded that i make her a muffin
immediately and i told her that i could not at that time. She started
yelling at me and stormed out of the store, it was about 15:10 when i
noticed that she did not actually leave the parking lot, i witnessed her
from my cash register pick up a brick that was outside my store and
start hitting the door and windows of my property, she cracked the
windows of my store and did not stop until a bylaw enforcement officer
pulled into the parking lot in front of my store. This lady was a regular
customer and caused severe damage to my property. It was about
15:30 when she finally stopped hitting the brick against my property.
She left shortly after the bylaw enforcement officer arrived. I have
cameras at my store that captured all of the incident and because the
customer is a regular i know her identity as Jane Doe.

PAGE1 OF 1

WITNESS NAME:.Jake ROE

DATE OF BIRTH:May 23 1 979

ADDRESS:12 Kilbridge Drive, Whitby, ON, L1T3G8

PHONE NUMBER:905 888 9898

WITNESS SIGNATURE: DATE:.FEB 11, 2023

Your name, date of birth, address, and telephone number are requested in case additional information is needed or if you are
needed for a court appearance pertaining to this case. If you would like to remain anonymous, please do not complete this form as
we will not be able to use the information provided. If you provide your name or other personal information it may be disclosed,
even if you request to remain anonymous. All information collected by this agency is made available to the public in accordance with
the Public Records Act.
 '{•SS^^'ss^^-'^w^^^i

A certified copy of Mr. Roe's business license for the store that was damaged.
 It^t^^-^ ^^s"^'^

';:ms:!s<S

:^SSS!^S3SHSS9SS£WSSSS9!i€s3SSiKSSSiSwfiy^ ^S. ^^1

This is a sworn affidavit from Lily Gibbons on her account of what happened on February 11th
2023, between 15:00 until 15:30 at 3050 garden St, Whitby, ON L1R 2G7.